difference between BLE, NFC and RFID

Do the terms RFID, BLE and NFC sound familar. Surely in this age one would have heard about them but with a constant lingering question in your mind – how do they work and what are their differences?

What is RFID and How does it work?

 

RFID stands for Radio Frequency Identification. Typically one can see these implemented in shopping malls as tags that are attached to items. These tags are used to sound of the beeper at the exits if the tags are not taken off indicating that it was not billed (tags are taken off once billed at the billing counter).  These tags have information stored in them and are typically passive. They use the radio energy from the reader to reflect back the information stored. The dis-advantage with methods like a bar-code is that it needs to be in the line of site to be read where as RFID tags be embedded in the object and it can be read.

rfid antenna

What is BLE and How does it work?

 

BLE is an acronym for Bluetooth Low Energy. Although it is called Bluetooth there is a difference between this and normal Bluetooth that we are using on our mobile devices.

In normal Bluetooth devices, the energy consumed is much higher than the of BLE devices. Regular Bluetooth operates in the frequency range 2400-2483.5 MHz through one of the designated 79 Bluetooth channels. Traditionally it is used for transferring a lot of data continuously for a longer duration in a short distance in M2M scenarios like transfer of files etc.

The BLE came in as part of Bluetooth 4.0 in 2011. It is typically used in short spurts of data transfer and the energy consumption is very low. A low-power device can last for 4 + years. It sends data for a couple of milliseconds while regular Bluetooth connects for 100s of milliseconds. The data transfer rates for BLE are also very high. BLE is not voice compatible.

The Bluetooth Smart Ready devices can connect with regular Bluetooth, Bluetooth Smart, or any Smart Ready device. A regular Bluetooth device is compatible with Bluetooth & Bluetooth Smart whereas a Bluetooth Smart device can only connect with Blue Tooth Smart device only. Regular Bluetooth has a limit of 100m while the BLE is greater than 100m.

how ble works

What is NFC and How does it work?

 

NFC stands for Near Field Communication, these devices too work on the Radio waves technology. It works by the principle of induction. It transmits at 13.56 megahertz with a max speed of  424 kilobits per second. Most tags are passive devices that contain an antenna and a microchip. The antenna is a coil and the NFC device picks power from the magnetic field. This power is used by the NFC tag to transmit information. Thus the magnetic field provides a communication medium as well as power.

It has 3 modes – peer-to-peer, read-write, and card emulation. It is used for small information exchange or to do a small action and now a days for card payments. One advantage with NFC is that it requires even lesser power than Bluetooth but this comes at a cost that the max range is very less to few inches while the Bluetooth goes 10m with the latest Bluetooth 5.0 going to 40m. Another big advantage with NFC is that there is no pairing needed and the connection is fast but the speed is low 424 kbps while it is 2Mbps in Bluetooth.

how nfc works

How are RFId, BLE and NFC different?

nfc icon
rfc-icon
ble
FAST

FAST

Faster connection using induced electric current currents

FAST

FAST

Connection in case of RFID is fast too since this too works with similar principles as NFC

FASTEST

FASTEST

BLE operates over 2.4Ghz and 2Mbps. Fastest wireless connection

< 0.2m

< 0.2m

The operational range is very less to close to inches.

5 Meters

5 Meters

The operational range is 5 meters

40m - 100m

40m - 100m

The operational range is about 150 meters in plain line of sight

VERY SMALL INFO

VERY SMALL INFO

Amount of information that can be exchanged is very low

SMALL INFO

SMALL INFO

Amount of information that can be exchanged is very low

LARGE INFO

LARGE INFO

With more than 156kb of memory, BLE chips and exchange a lot of information, both ways.

TWO WAY

TWO WAY

Information is sent in both directions, the nfc tags not only give out info, it can be even written in to by other nfc tags.

ONE WAY

ONE WAY

Here the RFID tag typically sends out information.

TWO WAY

TWO WAY

Information can not only be sent to the closest receiver but with Bluetooth Mesh, this information could be sent to the intended receiver which could be more than a mile away without internet or wifi.